| Platinum | Cha Cha's Hiland Bakery |
| Gold | On The Rise Bake Shop |
| Silver | The Cookie Jar |
| Bronze | Sweet Treat Without Wheat |
| Top Pick | Cinnaholic |
| Top Pick | Eileen's Cookies |
| Top Pick | La Mie Bakery |
| Top Pick | Linda Donuts |
| Top Pick | Little Rolling Pin Bakery |
| Top Pick | Scenic Route Bakery |