| Platinum | Bianchi's Hilltop Lounge & Restaurant |
| Gold | Scornovacca's Pizza |
| Silver | Abbie's Pizza |
| Bronze | Chuck's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Big Tomato Pizza CO |
| Top Pick | Bordenaros Pizza & Pasta |
| Top Pick | Casey's General Store |
| Top Pick | Gusto Pizza |
| Top Pick | Paul Revere's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Truman's KC Pizza Tavern |