| Platinum | Animal Rescue League of Iowa |
| Gold | Animal Lifeline of Iowa |
| Silver | Pet Sakes |
| Bronze | Bone-A-Patreat |
| Top Pick | Iowa Pet Foods & Seascapes |
| Top Pick | Paws & Pints |
| Top Pick | Pet Supplies Plus |
| Top Pick | The Pet Project |
| Top Pick | Wholesome Pet Essentials |
| Top Pick | Wild Things Pet Shop |