| Platinum | Tacos La Familia |
| Gold | El Fogon |
| Silver | Malo |
| Bronze | Panka |
| Top Pick | 5 de Mayo Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Abelardo Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Buzzard Billy's |
| Top Pick | Guadalajara |
| Top Pick | LA Cabaña Mexican Bar and Grill |
| Top Pick | Old West Mexican |