| Platinum | OPA! Italian & Greek |
| Gold | Gazali's |
| Silver | Olympic Flame Restaurant |
| Bronze | Open Sesame |
| Top Pick | Fresh Mediterranean Express |
| Top Pick | Garbanzo Mediterranean Fresh |
| Top Pick | Hummus Mediterranean Grill |
| Top Pick | Irina's Restaurant and Bar |
| Top Pick | St. Kilda Surf & Turf |
| Top Pick | Teds Coney Island West |